headroom/REALIGNMENT/03-phase-A-lockdown.md

Phase A — Cache-Safety Lockdown

Goal: Stop the cache-killer bleeding tonight. Each PR is small, low-risk, independently reversible. Zero new architecture; minimum viable fixes only.

Calendar: 1 week. PR-A1 lands today; A2–A8 over the week.

Shape: 8 PRs, each on its own branch, each in its own worktree. Sequential dependency only between A1→A4; the rest are parallelizable.

---

PR-A1 — Make /v1/messages compression a passthrough

Branch: realign-A1-icm-passthrough Worktree: ~/claude-projects/headroom-worktrees/realign-A1-icm-passthrough Risk: LOW (deletion + tests; no new logic) LOC: -180 / +30

Scope

Stop calling ICM from the Rust proxy on /v1/messages. The proxy becomes a pure byte-faithful passthrough on this endpoint. Zero compression value temporarily, but eliminates the C1+C2+C3+C4 cache-killer cluster (P0-3, P0-4, P0-5, P1-13). Compression returns in Phase B.

Files

Delete:

• crates/headroom-proxy/src/compression/icm.rs

Modify:

• crates/headroom-proxy/src/compression/mod.rs — remove pub mod icm;, remove ICM dispatch in maybe_compress. The is_compressible_path check still matches /v1/messages but compress_anthropic_request becomes a no-op stub returning Outcome::NoCompression.
• crates/headroom-proxy/src/compression/anthropic.rs — replace function body with Ok(Outcome::NoCompression). Keep the function signature so callers compile; subsequent PRs in Phase B replace this with the live-zone block dispatcher.
• crates/headroom-proxy/src/proxy.rs — confirm the Outcome::NoCompression branch forwards original bytes (already does at line 296-298; just verify with the new test).

Tests added:

• crates/headroom-proxy/tests/integration_compression.rs::compression_on_message_passes_body_unchanged_sha256 — record a real Anthropic request body to a fixture; send through proxy; assert SHA-256 of upstream-received body equals SHA-256 of inbound body.

Tests deleted/updated:

• Update compression_on_short_body_passes_through to assert SHA-256 byte-equality (not just len()).
• Update compression_on_long_body_drops_messages — rename to compression_on_long_body_passes_through_in_phase_A. The old assertion (fewer messages arrived) becomes the opposite (same messages arrive).

Acceptance criteria

• cargo test -p headroom-proxy green.
• New SHA-256 round-trip test passes.
• The proxy still starts and serves /healthz.
• make ci-precheck green.

Blocked by

None. Land first.

Blocks

PR-A4 (cache_control honoring needs the ICM call site removed first to avoid conflict). All Phase B PRs (which delete the surrounding code).

Rollback

git revert the merge commit. ICM is restored. (Note: this also restores P0-3 and P0-4. Acceptable for ~hours during emergency rollback.)

Notes

• The compress_anthropic_request function stays as a stub so Phase B has a single rewrite target.
• This PR does NOT delete ICM the module yet — crates/headroom-core/src/context/manager.rs still compiles. PR-B1 deletes the modules. Splitting keeps the diff scoped.

---

PR-A2 — Stop mutating the system prompt; route memory context to live zone

Branch: realign-A2-system-prompt-immutable Worktree: ~/claude-projects/headroom-worktrees/realign-A2-system-prompt-immutable Risk: MEDIUM (touches memory feature behavior) LOC: -150 / +80

Scope

Eliminate P0-1 and P2-23. The system prompt is never mutated; memory context is appended to the latest user message tail (live zone). Delete the cache_aligner rewrite path; keep the volatile-content detector for warnings only.

Files

Modify:

• headroom/proxy/server.py:1026-1071 — delete _inject_system_context. Memory context handling routes exclusively through _append_context_to_latest_non_frozen_user_turn (already exists at handlers/anthropic.py:1117-1135 for cache mode; promote to default).
• headroom/proxy/handlers/openai.py:1212 — same: delete body["instructions"] = f"{existing_instructions}\n\n{memory_context}". Replace with append-to-latest-user-message-tail.
• headroom/transforms/cache_aligner.py — delete the rewrite path (lines 160-262). Keep the volatile-content detector and the cache_aligner_warnings callback that surfaces detected dynamic content (UUIDs, dates, tokens) to a customer-visible log line.
• headroom/proxy/server.py:299 — cache_aligner.enabled flag stays default-False; document that turning it on now only affects warnings.

Tests added:

• tests/test_proxy_system_prompt_immutable.py::test_memory_enabled_does_not_mutate_system — request with memory enabled; assert outbound system bytes equal inbound system bytes.
• tests/test_proxy_system_prompt_immutable.py::test_memory_context_appears_in_user_tail — same request; assert memory context appears in the last user message's tail.
• tests/test_cache_aligner_detector_only.py::test_volatile_content_detected_warned_not_rewritten — system prompt with UUID; assert detector emits warning log; assert system bytes unchanged.

Tests deleted/updated:

• tests/test_cache_aligner_rewrite_*.py — delete; rewrite path is gone.

Acceptance criteria

• All new tests pass.
• Existing memory tests still pass (the live-zone-tail append should produce equivalent semantics).
• No regression in tests/test_proxy_anthropic_cache_stability.py.

Blocked by

None. Parallel with A1.

Blocks

PR-B6 (memory subsystem refactor, which builds on this).

Rollback

git revert the merge commit. Memory injection returns to system prompt. P0-1 returns.

---

PR-A3 — Switch Python forwarders to byte-faithful body forwarding

Branch: realign-A3-byte-faithful-forwarders Worktree: ~/claude-projects/headroom-worktrees/realign-A3-byte-faithful-forwarders Risk: HIGH (touches every outbound HTTP call in Python) LOC: -200 / +250

Scope

Eliminate P0-2 universally. Every Python forwarder switches from httpx ... json=body to httpx ... content=raw_bytes. When body was mutated by a transform, re-serialize once with separators=(",", ":"), ensure_ascii=False, and the original encoding. When unmutated, forward the original await request.body() verbatim.

Files

Modify:

• headroom/proxy/server.py:1073-1124 — _retry_request: track whether body was mutated; if not, forward original_body_bytes; if yes, re-serialize with the canonical settings. Switch await self.http_client.post(url, json=body) to await self.http_client.post(url, content=outbound_bytes, headers={**headers, "content-type": "application/json"}).
• headroom/proxy/handlers/streaming.py:617-660 — same pattern in _send_streaming_request.
• headroom/proxy/handlers/openai.py:2392-2410 — WS→HTTP fallback: same pattern.
• headroom/proxy/handlers/batch.py:340-360 — batch endpoint: same pattern.
• headroom/proxy/helpers.py — add serialize_body_canonical(body: dict) -> bytes helper using json.dumps(body, separators=(",", ":"), ensure_ascii=False).encode("utf-8").

Tests added:

• tests/test_proxy_byte_faithful_forwarding.py::test_passthrough_no_mutation_byte_equal — request with no compression / memory / transforms; assert SHA-256 of upstream-received body equals SHA-256 of client-sent body.
• tests/test_proxy_byte_faithful_forwarding.py::test_compression_off_unicode_preserved — request with 🔥 and CJK chars in user message; assert no \uXXXX escaping at upstream.
• tests/test_proxy_byte_faithful_forwarding.py::test_compression_off_numeric_precision_preserved — request with temperature: 1.0 and seed: 12345678901234567; assert exact bytes.

Acceptance criteria

• New byte-faithful tests pass.
• Existing test suite green.
• Manual smoke test: send a real request through the proxy with tcpdump or a recording mock; verify the bytes hitting upstream match a direct-to-Anthropic baseline.

Blocked by

None. Parallel with A1, A2.

Blocks

PR-A6 (memory tool injection refactor relies on the new mutation-tracking helper).

Rollback

git revert. The httpx json= defaults return.

Notes

• This is the highest-impact single PR for cache hit rate. Test coverage carefully.
• httpx.AsyncClient defaults set Content-Length from the bytes; verify no Transfer-Encoding chunked drift.
• The accept-encoding header strip stays for now; Phase F PR-F2 makes it conditional on auth mode.

---

PR-A4 — Honor customer cache_control markers in Rust; enable arbitrary_precision+raw_value

Branch: realign-A4-honor-cache-control Worktree: ~/claude-projects/headroom-worktrees/realign-A4-honor-cache-control Risk: MEDIUM (Rust-only; tightly scoped) LOC: -30 / +200

Scope

Eliminate P0-3 and P0-5 directly. In Rust, walk customer-set cache_control markers in system, tools, and messages; compute the effective frozen_message_count. Switch serde_json to arbitrary_precision + raw_value features. Use &RawValue for messages[*] so unmodified messages forward as exact byte copies. The compress_anthropic_request function is currently a no-op stub (per A1) — this PR adds the cache_control parser as preparation for Phase B.

Files

Modify:

• Cargo.toml:34 — add features: serde_json = { version = "1", features = ["preserve_order", "arbitrary_precision", "raw_value"] }. Run cargo update -p serde_json.
• crates/headroom-proxy/src/compression/anthropic.rs — add pub fn compute_frozen_count(parsed: &serde_json::Value) -> usize that walks messages[*].content[*].cache_control, system[*].cache_control, tools[*].cache_control and returns the highest message index whose content contains a marker. (Used by Phase B; currently called only by tests.)
• crates/headroom-core/src/lib.rs — re-export compute_frozen_count for use in Phase B.

Add:

• crates/headroom-proxy/tests/integration_cache_control.rs::cache_control_marker_at_message_3_yields_frozen_count_3
• crates/headroom-proxy/tests/integration_cache_control.rs::cache_control_in_system_blocks_yields_frozen_count_full_history
• crates/headroom-proxy/tests/integration_cache_control.rs::cache_control_ttl_1h_before_5m_passes
• crates/headroom-proxy/tests/integration_cache_control.rs::cache_control_ttl_5m_before_1h_warns_and_passes (we don't reject, but log per §2.19 ordering rule)

Acceptance criteria

• cargo build -p headroom-proxy works with new features.
• cargo test -p headroom-proxy green.
• The compute_frozen_count returns 0 for a request with zero markers; returns N for a request with a marker on messages[N].

Blocked by

PR-A1 (the call site needs to be removed before this can land cleanly).

Blocks

PR-B2 (live-zone block dispatcher uses compute_frozen_count).

Rollback

git revert. The Cargo features stay (harmless).

Notes

• RawValue is enabled but not yet consumed in this PR. Phase B PR-B2 wires it.
• Per guide §2.19, 1h markers must precede 5m markers; we log a warning when the ordering is reversed but don't reject (the customer's request, not ours to validate).

---

PR-A5 — Strip x-headroom-* from upstream-bound headers

Branch: realign-A5-strip-headroom-headers Worktree: ~/claude-projects/headroom-worktrees/realign-A5-strip-headroom-headers Risk: LOW LOC: -10 / +50

Scope

Eliminate P5-49. dict(request.headers.items()) is captured unmodified and forwarded; this PR adds an explicit strip step before any upstream call. Reduces fingerprint surface for subscription detection.

Files

Modify:

• headroom/proxy/handlers/anthropic.py:526 — wrap dict(request.headers.items()) with _strip_internal_headers(headers) (new helper).
• headroom/proxy/handlers/openai.py:232-264 — same.
• headroom/proxy/handlers/streaming.py:617 — same.
• headroom/proxy/handlers/batch.py:340 — same.
• headroom/proxy/handlers/gemini.py:31 — same.
• headroom/proxy/helpers.py — add _strip_internal_headers helper. Default strip list: x-headroom-* (case-insensitive prefix), plus a hardcoded set of internal flags.
• crates/headroom-proxy/src/headers.rs — add strip_internal_headers to the request-side filter. Document that response-side X-Headroom-* injection (which is fine) is unrelated.

Tests added:

• tests/test_header_isolation.py::test_x_headroom_bypass_not_forwarded
• tests/test_header_isolation.py::test_x_headroom_mode_not_forwarded
• tests/test_header_isolation.py::test_x_headroom_user_id_not_forwarded
• crates/headroom-proxy/tests/integration_headers.rs::x_headroom_request_headers_stripped

Acceptance criteria

• New tests pass.
• Existing client-driven x-headroom-bypass: true flow still works (proxy reads it; just doesn't forward).
• No legitimate header is stripped (whitelist x-request-id, x-trace-id, etc. by default — though they aren't x-headroom-* so they're untouched).

Blocked by

None. Parallel.

Blocks

PR-F2 (auth-mode policy uses this helper).

Rollback

git revert. Headers leak again. Low operational risk.

---

PR-A6 — Pin anthropic-beta order; session-stickiness skeleton

Branch: realign-A6-anthropic-beta-stable Worktree: ~/claude-projects/headroom-worktrees/realign-A6-anthropic-beta-stable Risk: MEDIUM (touches memory injection beta-mutation) LOC: -40 / +180

Scope

Eliminate P5-50 and start P5-51. When the proxy mutates anthropic-beta (memory injection), the new comma-list is computed deterministically (sort tokens or preserve insertion order with new tokens appended). Add a per-session "betas seen so far" tracker so any beta seen in turn N is included in turn N+1 even if the client drops it.

Files

Modify:

• headroom/proxy/handlers/anthropic.py:1162-1168 — replace the ad-hoc concat with a helper merge_anthropic_beta(client: str, headroom: list[str]) -> str that splits client's value on ,, lowercases each token, deduplicates, appends Headroom-required tokens (sorted within the appended group), and rejoins.
• headroom/proxy/server.py — extend session_state (already exists for memory) to track betas_seen: set[str] per session. Update on every request; merge into outbound anthropic-beta for follow-up requests.
• headroom/proxy/helpers.py — add betas_seen_lock and update_session_betas helpers.

Tests added:

• tests/test_anthropic_beta_session_sticky.py::test_beta_seen_turn_1_present_in_turn_2_even_if_client_drops
• tests/test_anthropic_beta_session_sticky.py::test_memory_injection_appends_deterministic_order
• tests/test_anthropic_beta_session_sticky.py::test_client_value_preserved_when_no_injection

Acceptance criteria

• New tests pass.
• Session ID is keyed off the existing session detection (per headroom/proxy/handlers/anthropic.py:1417).
• The "betas seen" set is bounded (LRU eviction at 1000 sessions).

Blocked by

PR-A3 (relies on byte-faithful forwarder for header-bytes correctness; if A3 is rolled back, this still works but is less effective).

Blocks

PR-A7 (memory tool session-stickiness uses the same session-state plumbing).

Rollback

git revert. Beta header drift returns; functional but degraded cache safety.

---

PR-A7 — Memory tool injection session-sticky

Branch: realign-A7-memory-tool-sticky Worktree: ~/claude-projects/headroom-worktrees/realign-A7-memory-tool-sticky Risk: MEDIUM LOC: -30 / +150

Scope

Eliminate the rest of P0-6. Once memory injects a tool into body["tools"] for a session, every subsequent request in that session also injects the same tool (same name, same definition bytes). Toggling off mid-session is forbidden.

Files

Modify:

• headroom/proxy/memory_tool_adapter.py:625-657 — make injection session-state-aware. The session-state object grows a memory_tools_injected: bool and memory_tools_definition_bytes: bytes (golden form). On every request: if previously injected, inject again with byte-equal definition.
• headroom/proxy/memory_handler.py:389-398 — same: native-tool path becomes session-sticky.
• headroom/proxy/handlers/anthropic.py:1147-1171 — read session state; either inject all (if previously injected or memory enabled this turn) or none.

Tests added:

• tests/test_memory_tool_session_sticky.py::test_injection_in_turn_1_repeats_in_turn_2
• tests/test_memory_tool_session_sticky.py::test_byte_equal_tool_definition_across_turns
• tests/test_memory_tool_session_sticky.py::test_memory_disabled_after_inject_still_injects

Acceptance criteria

• New tests pass.
• The injected memory_* tool definitions are byte-stable across deploys (snapshot test pins the bytes).

Blocked by

PR-A6.

Blocks

PR-B6 (memory subsystem refactor).

Rollback

git revert. Toggling returns. P0-6 returns.

---

PR-A8 — Hotfix Python wire-format bugs; add SHA-256 round-trip test

Branch: realign-A8-python-wire-hotfix Worktree: ~/claude-projects/headroom-worktrees/realign-A8-python-wire-hotfix Risk: MEDIUM LOC: -100 / +400

Scope

Catch-all for the Python wire-format bugs that should be fixed before Phase H deletes the Python proxy. Specifically:

• P1-8: SSE byte-level decoding in streaming.py and ccr/response_handler.py.
• P1-9: Add thinking_delta, signature_delta, citations_delta arms to _parse_sse_to_response.
• P0-7 / P4-44: Preserve phase field in responses_converter.py; fix multi-text-part rebuild.
• P5-57 / P5-59: Capture upstream request-id in logs; fix body-size-cap status code (400 → 413).
• P4-47: Add a warning log line when responses_converter.py:99 hits an unknown item type.
• P6-63: New SHA-256 byte-faithful round-trip test on a recorded production payload.

Files

Modify:

• headroom/proxy/handlers/streaming.py:213-298 — rewrite _parse_sse_to_response to handle all delta types per guide §5.1. Add index-keyed block map. Bytes-level SSE buffer.
• headroom/proxy/handlers/streaming.py:58, 772 — switch chunk.decode("utf-8", errors="ignore") to a bytes-buffer + decode-after-\n\n pattern.
• headroom/ccr/response_handler.py:665-686 — same pattern.
• headroom/proxy/responses_converter.py:94, 235 — preserve phase explicitly. Fix multi-text-part rebuild: rebuild parts by index, replacing each part's text in place.
• headroom/proxy/responses_converter.py:99 — add logger.warning(f"unknown responses item type: {item.get('type')}").
• crates/headroom-proxy/src/proxy.rs:355-358 — capture upstream request-id (Anthropic) and x-request-id (OpenAI) into the tracing field.
• crates/headroom-proxy/src/proxy.rs:243-263 — return 413 on body-too-large; return 400 only on actual parse error.

Add:

• tests/fixtures/anthropic_messages_request_real.json — recorded production-shaped payload (sanitized).
• tests/test_proxy_byte_faithful_round_trip.py::test_sha256_round_trip_no_compression — boot proxy; send fixture; assert SHA-256 byte-equal at upstream mock.
• tests/test_proxy_responses_phase_preservation.py::test_codex_phase_commentary_preserved
• tests/test_proxy_responses_phase_preservation.py::test_codex_phase_final_answer_preserved
• tests/test_sse_thinking_blocks.py::test_thinking_delta_accumulated
• tests/test_sse_thinking_blocks.py::test_signature_delta_preserved
• tests/test_sse_thinking_blocks.py::test_citations_delta_accumulated
• tests/test_sse_utf8_split.py::test_emoji_split_across_chunks_preserved
• crates/headroom-proxy/tests/integration_request_id.rs::upstream_request_id_captured

Acceptance criteria

• All new tests pass.
• Pre-existing test suite green.
• Manual streaming smoke test with thinking blocks + signatures.

Blocked by

None. Parallel with A2-A7.

Blocks

None directly; Phase C builds on the Rust SSE work but doesn't depend on this Python fix.

Rollback

git revert. Wire-format bugs return; subsequent Phase C will re-fix in Rust anyway.

Notes

• This is a "hotfix the Python proxy enough to be safe until Phase H deletes it" PR. Not investing in pretty Python here — just safety.
• The recorded fixture in tests/fixtures/anthropic_messages_request_real.json should include: thinking + signature blocks, tool_use with non-trivial JSON input, mixed-key schemas, non-ASCII content, large numbers, cache_control markers in messages and system.

---

Phase A acceptance summary

After all 8 PRs land:

• ✅ ICM no longer drops messages from cache hot zone
• ✅ Customer cache_control markers honored in Rust
• ✅ System prompt never mutated
• ✅ Memory context routes to live-zone tail
• ✅ Memory tool injection session-sticky
• ✅ anthropic-beta mutation deterministic + session-sticky
• ✅ Python forwarders byte-faithful
• ✅ x-headroom-* stripped from upstream
• ✅ Numeric precision preserved (RawValue + arbitrary_precision)
• ✅ SSE thinking/signature/citations deltas handled
• ✅ Codex phase preserved
• ✅ Upstream request-id captured
• ✅ SHA-256 byte-faithful round-trip test gating CI

Phase A retires P0-1 through P0-7 and P1-8, P1-9, P5-49, P5-50, P5-57, P5-59, P6-63.