No description
Find a file
Rob 4ecb88549e Merge branch 'deps/reticulum-go-v0.6.2'
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01XdCVMpGfBJSGPfj6Hs5jnV
2026-08-28 12:44:30 -04:00
.github/workflows Depend on reticulum-go module (remove vendored internal/rns+lxmf) (#21) 2026-08-19 10:23:28 -04:00
cmd/fwdsvc chore: rename repo to reticulum-group-chat 2026-06-20 05:10:44 -04:00
configs Validate and charge inbound §5.7 stamps, opt-in 2026-08-28 05:56:31 -04:00
docs deps: reticulum-go v0.5.0 -> v0.6.0; refuse multi-segment resources 2026-08-28 06:20:35 -04:00
internal v1.17.3: per-sender bound on inbound stamp validation work 2026-08-28 12:44:30 -04:00
scripts v1.1.0: outbound link delivery + lifecycle + uncapped /users 2026-05-08 07:34:00 -04:00
tests/interop Depend on reticulum-go module (remove vendored internal/rns+lxmf) (#21) 2026-08-19 10:23:28 -04:00
.gitignore feat(locked): invite-only groups via /adduser + /removeuser 2026-07-18 20:45:32 -04:00
go.mod deps: reticulum-go v0.6.1 -> v0.6.2 2026-08-28 12:44:29 -04:00
go.sum deps: reticulum-go v0.6.1 -> v0.6.2 2026-08-28 12:44:29 -04:00
README.md deps: reticulum-go v0.5.0 -> v0.6.0; refuse multi-segment resources 2026-08-28 06:20:35 -04:00

reticulum-group-chat (fwdsvc)

A Reticulum group chat. fwdsvc is a small daemon that hosts a multi-user text chat over the Reticulum Network, using LXMF for message delivery. Each chat is one running service. Anyone with the service's destination hash can /join, send messages, and have them fanned out to every other member — a many-to-many group chat over whatever Reticulum transport(s) you have available (LoRa, TCP/IP, your own mesh, etc.).

If you've used IRC, Matrix, or Telegram groups, the user experience is similar. The difference is that the chat travels over Reticulum, so it works on radios with no Internet, can be relayed across mixed LoRa+TCP+I2P meshes, and the operator is just one person running this binary on a Pi.

  • No third-party Reticulum library. Pure-Go implementation of the protocol layers we need, written directly against the spec.
  • Verified against upstream Python rns + LXMF at the byte level (static test vectors plus a live subprocess interop harness running on CI).
  • Live-tested end-to-end with Sideband, NomadNet, and MeshChat over public Reticulum testnet entry nodes.
  • One static binary — runs unattended on a Raspberry Pi, a Debian server, macOS, or Windows. No runtime, no Python, no daemon zoo.

Table of contents

  1. What this is, and how it works
  2. Features
  3. Install and first run
  4. Commands
  5. Configuration reference
  6. Deployment recipes
  7. Operations
  8. Wire-format support
  9. Reactions: what a client must implement
  10. Limitations
  11. Build from source
  12. Project info

What this is, and how it works

Reticulum gives every participant a cryptographic identity — a keypair stored in a small file. From the identity you derive a destination hash, a 16-byte address other peers route to. Reticulum announces propagate destination → identity bindings across the mesh so anyone in range can encrypt to anyone else.

LXMF rides on top of Reticulum: signed, encrypted, store-and-forward messages addressed to a destination hash, deliverable opportunistically (one Reticulum packet) or over a Reticulum Link for larger payloads.

fwdsvc is one LXMF endpoint that behaves like a chatroom:

┌──────────┐                ┌──────────┐                ┌──────────┐
│ Alice    │   /join, msg   │ fwdsvc   │   forwarded    │ Bob      │
│ Sideband │ ─────────────▶ │ daemon   │ ─────────────▶ │ NomadNet │
└──────────┘                │          │                └──────────┘
                            │ roster:  │
┌──────────┐                │  Alice   │                ┌──────────┐
│ Carol    │   /join, msg   │  Bob     │   forwarded    │ Dave     │
│ MeshChat │ ─────────────▶ │  Carol   │ ─────────────▶ │ Sideband │
└──────────┘                │  Dave    │                └──────────┘
                            └──────────┘
  • Each message Alice sends to the daemon's destination hash is forwarded to every other member of the roster, prefixed with [Alice] so receivers see who said what.
  • The daemon never sees plaintext from any peer except via its own identity's decryption, and it re-encrypts per recipient on the way out — same trust model as any LXMF peer.
  • Joining is by sending /join. Roster membership is auto-pruned for anyone not heard from (no announce, no message) for four weeks, and for lurkers who keep announcing but never send a chat message for six weeks, by default.

Glossary

Term Meaning
Identity 64-byte X25519 + Ed25519 keypair on disk (or in service.identity_b64). Lost identity = lost destination hash = your roster has to re-add you.
Destination hash 16-byte / 32-hex-char address. The thing your users put in their LXMF client to message the service.
Announce A signed broadcast that teaches the mesh "destination D belongs to identity I, reachable via these hops." fwdsvc re-announces itself every announce_interval (default 10 min).
Roster The set of members. Living in state.json.
Replay When a new member joins, the daemon ships them the most recent N messages so they can pick up the conversation.
Opportunistic / Link / Resource The three LXMF delivery paths, picked automatically by payload size. See Wire-format support.

Features

  • Explicit /join opt-in. A first message from a stranger gets a private invitation reply, not a forward. Avoids the "I sent one test message and now strangers are getting it" UX.
  • Default nickname from announces. A member with no nickname set picks one up automatically from their announced display name, sanitised to [A-Za-z0-9_-]{1,24} ("Bob & Alice""Bob_Alice"; all-emoji collapses to empty and stays unset). Applied at /join time and on every subsequent announce until a nickname exists, so a user who joined before their first announce arrived still gets named once it does. /nick is authoritative: once set, announces never overwrite.
  • Replay on join. New (and returning) members receive the most recent buffered messages so they can read the prior conversation. Defaults: last 100 messages, nothing older than 7 days. Configurable.
  • Pause without leaving. A member can /pause to stop receiving (and sending) forwards while staying on the roster. /resume reverses.
  • Per-message char cap (max_inbound_chars, default 500). Oversize non-command messages get a polite reject reply and aren't forwarded.
  • Auto-prune. Members not heard from for prune_after (default 4 weeks) are removed automatically. A second window, prune_silent_after (default 6 weeks), also removes lurkers who keep announcing (or run the odd command) but never send a chat message. Either way they can /join again any time.
  • Forwarded content sanitised. Bytes outside printable + TAB/LF/CR become ? before forwarding — no ANSI-escape injection into other users' terminals.
  • Outbound retry queue. Every outbound message goes through a persistent queue mirroring LXMF's LXMRouter.process_outbound policy: 5 attempts with exponential backoff (10 s doubling to a 60 s cap), 7-second path?-backed defer when the recipient hasn't announced. Survives restarts via outbound.json. Drained by an 8-worker pool so a slow send to one recipient doesn't block command replies to others. Picker prioritises by recipient recency (peers we just heard announce go first).
  • Announce cache survives restart. Verified announces persist to announces.json — after a restart, every previously-known peer is immediately addressable instead of waiting up to one announce_interval for them to re-announce. Entries older than 30 days are dropped at load time.
  • Three LXMF delivery paths, picked automatically. Opportunistic (one packet, fire-and-forget) for small replies; Link DATA (one Token-framed packet over a Reticulum Link) for medium payloads; SPEC §10 Resource transfer for anything bigger (long /users replies on big rosters, long chat messages, etc.).
  • Propagation-node store-and-forward (opt-in, v1.13.0+). With [propagation] enabled = true, messages that exhaust their direct retry budget are handed to an LXMF propagation node (SPEC §5.8) instead of dropped — offline members get them on their client's next sync. Nodes are auto-discovered from lxmf.propagation announces (or pinned by hash), the node's declared per-transfer limit is respected, and required §5.7 proof-of-work stamps are ground automatically. mode = "always" routes everything via the node. See [propagation].
  • Mod / admin moderation. Config-file admins and mods lists get /kick, /ban, /unban, /announce, /path, and the cross-user form of /nick. Admins can also grant/clear roles at runtime with /usermode — no config edit or restart.
  • Invite-only (locked) groups. Set locked = true and /join is refused for everyone except config admins/mods; the only way in is a mod/admin running /adduser <hash>, which adds the user and sends them a welcome + replay. /removeuser takes them back out. Config admins/mods are auto-enrolled as members at startup so the operator actually receives messages. See Private (invite-only) groups.
  • Duplicate suppression. Inbound messages are de-duplicated by LXMF message_id within dedup_window (default 1h), so a message Reticulum delivers more than once (multi-path, retransmit, propagation-node replay) is fanned out only once. A single-instance lock also refuses to start a second daemon on the same state_path — the other classic cause of echoed messages.
  • Bind-once identity. Embed your identity in config.toml via identity_b64 and the config file is the single source of truth — reinstall on any machine, same destination hash, same chat for everyone.
  • Self-healing TCP interface. tcp_client interfaces auto-redial with capped exponential backoff after any drop (peer restart, NAT timeout, transient network failure). TCP keepalive on dialed sockets surfaces silent peer drops within ~2 minutes instead of waiting for the next outbound write to fail. The service does not need to be restarted after an upstream blip.

Install and first run

1. Get the binary

Download the latest release for your platform:

Asset Target
fwdsvc-linux-amd64 x86_64 Linux (Debian/Ubuntu/etc.)
fwdsvc-linux-arm64 ARM64 Linux (RPi 4/5 64-bit, most ARM SBCs)
fwdsvc-linux-armv7 32-bit ARMv7 (RPi 2/3 32-bit)
fwdsvc-linux-armv6 32-bit ARMv6 (RPi Zero, RPi 1)
fwdsvc-darwin-arm64 Apple Silicon macOS
fwdsvc-windows-amd64.exe x86_64 Windows

On Linux/macOS, chmod +x fwdsvc-… after download.

Or build from source.

Third-party packages

fwdsvc is also packaged for Nix / NixOS in nixpkgs (contributed by @drupol — thank you).

Third-party packages are maintained independently of this project. We don't control when they update, so a packaged build can sit several releases behind — which matters here, because releases have included security fixes and fixes for messages being silently dropped. If you install from a package manager, check that

fwdsvc --version

matches the latest release. If it doesn't, prefer the release binary above or a source build until the package catches up.

2. Make a config

mkdir -p ~/.fwdsvc
curl -L https://raw.githubusercontent.com/thatSFguy/reticulum-group-chat/main/configs/fwdsvc.example.toml \
  -o ~/.fwdsvc/config.toml

Open ~/.fwdsvc/config.toml and edit:

  • display_name — what your service shows in its announces. Visible to every Reticulum node it reaches.
  • [[interfaces]] addr — a reachable Reticulum peer to dial. A community testnet node (rns.chicagonomad.net:4242, rns.michmesh.net:7822, etc.) works for getting started; for production you'd point at a local rnsd you control or your own TCP-attached gateway.
  • Leave admins = [] for now; you'll add yourself in step 4.

3. Run it once to generate an identity

./fwdsvc -config ~/.fwdsvc/config.toml

First lines on stdout:

fwdsvc 1.11.0 starting (linux/amd64)
fwdsvc 2026/05/11 16:00:00 interface tcp_client connected: rns.chicagonomad.net:4242
fwdsvc 2026/05/11 16:00:00 service identity hash: 359fc3967f984a529874d0960c6ee782
fwdsvc 2026/05/11 16:00:00 delivery destination : 4c87fb86ccfdff39a3d1e22060ba1789
fwdsvc 2026/05/11 16:00:00 display name        : My Group Chat

The delivery destination (second hash) is the address your users will message in their LXMF client. Share that with your group — it's the chat's stable identifier.

4. Add yourself as admin

From your LXMF client (Sideband on phone, NomadNet on desktop, MeshChat, etc.) send the service any short message. The forwarder will log:

new sender contact: full dest_hash = 0b0501efed0844bb064bc6df4cba43bb

Stop the service (Ctrl-C), put that 32-character hex string in admins, and restart:

admins = [
  "0b0501efed0844bb064bc6df4cba43bb",
]

Important: admins and mods MUST be top-level keys in config.toml, before any [section] header. TOML scopes top-level keys to whichever section is currently active, so putting them after [service] silently makes them service.admins.

5. Join from your client

From your LXMF client, send /join to the daemon's delivery destination. You'll get a confirmation reply and from now on every forwarded message from other members lands in your inbox.

Send /? to see the commands available to you (admins see the full moderation set).

Your friends do the same against the same delivery destination, and they're all in the chat.


Commands

/? (or /help) replies are role-aware — non-members only see commands that work for them, mods see the moderation set, admins see everything.

User commands

Command Who Effect
/? or /help anyone List commands available to you
/about or /version anyone Show version and repo URL
/users members List roster (paused members marked [paused]). Long rosters list the first 200 with a "… and N more" footer; the total is always shown.
/mods anyone List configured mods
/admin anyone List configured admins
/join non-members Opt in: receive forwarded messages, your messages get forwarded. In a locked group this is refused with your own address echoed back to hand to an admin.
/leave members Leave the chat (you can /join again later)
/pause members Stop receiving forwards (and stop forwarding yours)
/resume members Reverse /pause
/textonly members Skip attachments — receive only the text body of forwarded messages. Intended for users on slow / metered links.
/showall members Reverse /textonly — resume receiving attachments.
/nick <newname> members Change own nickname (124 chars from [A-Za-z0-9_-])

Mod / admin commands

Command Who Effect
/nick <user> <newname> mods, admins Change another user's nickname
/kick <user> mods, admins Remove from roster (user can /join again)
/ban <user> mods, admins Add to banlist; future /joins and messages refused
/unban <user> mods, admins Remove from banlist
/adduser <hash> mods, admins Add a user by their 32-hex destination hash — the invite path for a locked group. Adds them to the roster and sends a welcome + replay.
/removeuser <user> mods, admins Remove a member. In a locked group they can't return until re-added (unlike /kick, which lets them /join again in an open group). Not punitive like /ban.
/announce mods, admins Broadcast a fresh Reticulum announce immediately
/path <user> mods, admins Show what the transport knows about reaching <user>: cached announce age, hop count, next-hop transport_id, whether an Active Link is open. Mostly for troubleshooting delivery problems. The hop count is approximate: peers running RNS ≥ 1.3.7 with the local_hops_delta privacy option inflate it by a constant 27 (SPEC §2.4).
/usermode <admin|mod|user> <user> admins Grant or clear a runtime role for a roster member — no config edit or restart needed. admin/mod promote; user clears the runtime grant.

<user> accepts a nickname (case-insensitive) or a destination-hash prefix (≥ 4 hex chars). When two members would match the prefix, the daemon refuses with a disambiguation reply.

/usermode and the config lists. A runtime role only ever raises the role granted by the config admins/mods lists — it never lowers it. The effective role is max(config role, runtime role). So:

  • /usermode mod Alice promotes a regular member to mod; /usermode user Alice clears that grant again.
  • A role granted in the config file cannot be demoted from chat — if you /usermode user someone who is a config admin/mod, the daemon tells you their effective role is unchanged and to edit the config. This is deliberate: you can't strip a config-defined admin's powers from inside the room.
  • Runtime grants persist in the roster state file across restarts.
  • An admin can't clear their own runtime admin grant (anti-lockout); a config-defined admin is inherently safe.

Examples

> /join
Joined. You'll receive forwarded messages from now on. /pause to mute,
/leave to exit, /? for help.

> /nick Alice
Nickname set to Alice.

> /users
Users (3):
  Alice — 0b0501ef
  Bob — ffeeddcc
  (no nick) — 1234abcd

> Hi everyone!
(message fans out to Bob and the unnicked user with prefix `[Alice] Hi everyone!`)

Private (invite-only) groups

By default anyone with the destination hash can /join. Set locked = true under [service] to run a closed group:

  • /join from a regular user is refused with a "closed group" reply that echoes them their own destination hash to hand to an admin.
  • A mod/admin adds them with /adduser <hash> — the user is placed on the roster and sent a welcome plus replay, exactly as if they had joined. /removeuser <user> takes them back out; while locked they can't return until re-added.
  • Config admins/mods are auto-enrolled as members at startup, so the operator receives messages without a separate /join — being an admin grants command powers, not delivery, and this closes that gap. An admin who wants to moderate silently uses /pause; one who /leaves is re-enrolled on the next restart (remove them from the config to opt out for good).
  • Config admins/mods always bypass the lock, so you can't lock yourself out.

TOML gotcha: locked must sit under the [service] header. A locked = true placed above the first [section] is a top-level key that TOML silently ignores — the group stays open and /join still works. The startup log prints locked (invite-only): true; check it to confirm the setting took effect.


Configuration reference

The config is a single TOML file. Default location is ~/.fwdsvc/config.toml; override with -config <path>.

Root-level keys

Key Type Default Description
admins array of hex strings [] Destination hashes of admins. Get all the mod commands.
mods array of hex strings [] Destination hashes of mods. Get the moderation commands minus admin-only ones.

Both lists MUST be declared at the top of the file, before any [section] header.

[service]

Key Type Default Description
display_name string "Group Chat - send /join" Shown in announces.
identity_path path ~/.fwdsvc/identity Where the service's identity is stored. Ignored if identity_b64 is set.
identity_b64 string unset Base64 of the 64-byte identity. When set, this is authoritative and identity_path is ignored. See Identity backup.
state_path path ~/.fwdsvc/state.json Roster + banlist.
history_path path ~/.fwdsvc/history.json Replay ring buffer.
log_path path unset If set, append the daemon log to this file (in addition to stdout).
prune_after duration "4w" Drop a member we haven't heard from (no announce, no message) for this long.
prune_silent_after duration "6w" Drop a member who hasn't sent a chat message in this long, even if still announcing or running commands (/join resets it). 0 disables.
prune_interval duration "1h" How often the prune sweep runs.
announce_interval duration "10m" How often we re-announce ourselves.
max_inbound_chars int 500 Reject non-command messages longer than this many UTF-8 chars. 0 disables.
max_members int 512 Cap on roster size. /join past the cap is refused. Defaults to a bound rather than unlimited because in an open group anyone can mint identities and join, and roster size multiplies every fan-out. 0 = unlimited (not recommended unless locked = true).
locked bool false Invite-only mode. /join is refused for non-admins/mods; membership is managed with /adduser / /removeuser, and config admins/mods are auto-enrolled. See Private (invite-only) groups. Must be placed under [service].
inbound_stamp_cost int 0 SPEC §5.7.2 proof-of-work required of anyone messaging the group, announced in our app_data so senders know to pay it. Cost is in leading zero bits, so difficulty doubles per step — 8 is about a second on a phone, 16 is minutes. 0 announces no cost and checks nothing. The only limit here that charges the sender; everything else caps what we do after the message has arrived. Range 0254.
enforce_inbound_stamps bool false Drop messages that don't clear inbound_stamp_cost instead of accepting them and logging what they paid (SPEC §5.7.4; matches upstream LXMF's _enforce_stamps default). Watch the inbound stamp: log lines first — a client that doesn't implement stamps becomes silently undeliverable to the group the moment this goes on. Requires inbound_stamp_cost > 0.
dedup_window duration "1h" Remember each inbound message_id for this long and drop redeliveries (multi-path / retransmit / propagation replay) before forwarding. 0 disables.
forward_attachments bool true Pass LXMF non-text fields (images, etc.) through forwarding. false forwards text only; a sender whose file, image or audio is dropped is told so privately.
max_attachment_bytes int 1024000 (1000 KiB) Per-field msgpack size cap. Oversize attachments are dropped with an inline [image not forwarded: …] note on the forwarded body; text body still delivers. 0 disables the cap.
forwarded_fields int list [6, 48, 49, 64, 65, 66] Allowlist of LXMF field keys to forward when forward_attachments=true. Default covers FIELD_IMAGE (6) plus the upstream LXMF 1.0.0 message-meta fields: reply-to (FIELD_REPLY_TO 0x30=48 message-id, FIELD_REPLY_QUOTE 0x31=49 quoted text), tap-back reactions (FIELD_REACTION 0x40=64), comments (FIELD_COMMENT 0x41=65), and continuations (FIELD_CONTINUATION 0x42=66). Add 5 for files, 7 for audio once your senders/receivers handle them — until you do, a sender attaching one gets a private reply saying the group does not accept that kind.
id_cache_ttl duration 24h How long fwdsvc remembers each fan-out's per-recipient LXMF message_id so reactions and reply-to fields can be rewritten per recipient (v1.6.0+). 0 disables — reactions then show "[someone reacted]" without landing on a bubble. Going longer just grows memory; each cache entry is ~50 bytes × roster size.
id_cache_max int 10000 Hard cap on id_cache_ttl entry count (LRU evicts oldest). One fan-out to N recipients counts as N entries. 0 = unbounded.

Durations are Go time.ParseDuration plus d (days) and w (weeks): "30s", "5m", "24h", "7d", "4w".

[[interfaces]]

Repeated table — one entry per Reticulum I/O interface. Currently only tcp_client is supported.

Key Type Default Description
type string required "tcp_client".
addr string required host:port of a TCPServerInterface peer to dial.
timeout duration "0" Dial timeout. 0 = stdlib default (~30 s).
[[interfaces]]
type    = "tcp_client"
addr    = "rns.chicagonomad.net:4242"
timeout = "10s"

[[interfaces]]
type = "tcp_client"
addr = "10.0.0.42:4242"   # your own rnsd on the LAN

fwdsvc broadcasts on all interfaces; redundancy is fine.

[replay]

Key Type Default Description
count int 100 Max messages replayed when a member joins (or rejoins). 0 disables replay entirely.
max_age duration "7d" Skip messages older than this in replay.

[propagation]

Store-and-forward delivery via LXMF propagation nodes (SPEC §5.8). Disabled by default; existing deployments are unaffected.

Key Type Default Description
enabled bool false Turn propagation-node submission on.
mode string "fallback" "fallback": direct delivery first, re-route via the propagation node only after the direct retry budget (5 attempts) is exhausted. "always": every outbound message goes to the propagation node only — nothing is dropped for being offline, at the cost of sync latency.
node hex unset Pin a specific propagation node by its lxmf.propagation destination hash (32 hex chars). Most operators should leave this unset — see Choosing a propagation node. Unset = auto-select: among nodes that are accepting and whose announced parameters we can satisfy, the one known longest and heard from recently.
direct_attempts int 3 Shortens the direct retry budget, but only while a propagation node is available to fall back to — failing over after 3 attempts (~75 s) instead of the standard 5 (~3.5 min) gets an offline member's mail onto the node sooner. Whenever no node is known, the full 5-attempt budget still applies before a message is dropped. Both numbers are printed at startup. Set to 5 to disable the shortening. Fallback mode only.

Choosing a propagation node

Leave node unset and let auto-discovery pick, unless you know that your members all sync from one particular node. That caveat is doing the work — read on for why it usually doesn't apply.

The thing that decides whether store-and-forward works is not security, it is the fetch side: a message is only delivered once the recipient pulls it down. If this service uploads to node A and a member polls node B, delivery depends on A and B peering and syncing — best-effort, possibly slow, possibly never. Pinning is only a fix for that when everyone involved shares the same node.

Why auto is the right default. From one instance's log over five weeks (2026-06-20 → 2026-07-27, single hub, single vantage point — your view will differ):

Observation Count
Distinct nodes seen accepting messages 632
Distinct nodes seen refusing messages 236
Nodes that flapped between accepting and refusing 215
Propagation announces carrying a display name 0 of 2200

Each row argues against pinning blind:

  • 632 candidates. If members choose their own node independently, pinning one gives you a negligible chance of matching any given member. The determinism argument evaporates unless the group has genuinely agreed on a node.
  • 215 of them flapped. A third of the population goes in and out of accepting messages. Pin one of those and store-and-forward silently goes intermittent, with no failover. Auto-selection re-checks the accepting flag at selection time, so it routes around a node that has stopped taking mail.
  • No node advertises a name. Per SPEC §5.8.5 the lxmf.propagation announce app_data carries the 7-element parameter array, not a display string — every one of those 2200 announces had an empty name. There is no way to recognise "the community's node" from announces alone; someone has to hand you the hash out of band.

Auto-selection prefers the node known longest among those currently accepting and satisfiable, rather than the most recently heard. That resists a newcomer flooding announces to seize the role, and it selects for uptime — the one useful property you can still select for once locality is unknowable.

Pin a node when you actually know one: your own propagation node, or one the group has agreed on and whose hash you were given directly. In that case pinning is clearly better — it makes the round trip deterministic, prevents anyone claiming the role by announcing, and lets you choose which operator sees your traffic metadata.

The cost of pinning is failover. A pinned node is used unconditionally — if it goes offline or stops accepting, store-and-forward stops until it returns or you change the setting. Direct delivery to online members is unaffected either way, so the failure is bounded: you lose the safety net, not the service.

Set expectations either way. With a membership that uses assorted nodes, store-and-forward is a best-effort improvement rather than a guarantee — beyond the upload, delivery rests on inter-node syncing that no setting here influences. In mode = "fallback" that is still purely a win: the members it misses are the ones who would have received nothing at all. If you need it to be reliable, the fix is not a config value — run a propagation node for your community and have members point their clients at it.

Trust note. A propagation node cannot read your messages — bodies are encrypted to the recipient. It can see each recipient's destination hash (so over time, your roster), this service's identity, and the timing and size of everything sent. It can also silently discard what it is given. Submitted data cannot be recalled. In mode = "always" this covers every group message.

Notes:

  • Delivery to the node rides a Reticulum Link and succeeds when the node holds the message; the member's client (Sideband, MeshChat, …) fetches it on its next propagation sync. Members must have a propagation node configured client-side for this to reach them.
  • If the node's announce declares a stamp cost (§5.8.5), the required proof-of-work stamp is computed automatically, up to 20 bits — nodes demanding more are skipped at selection time (defense against a hostile announce pinning the CPU).
  • The node's announced per-transfer size limit is enforced before upload; oversize messages fail that route rather than being silently truncated.

Deployment recipes

  1. Put the binary in /usr/local/bin/fwdsvc and chmod 755 it.
  2. Create a system user:
    sudo useradd --system --home /var/lib/fwdsvc --create-home --shell /usr/sbin/nologin fwdsvc
    
  3. Put config.toml at /etc/fwdsvc/config.toml. Make sure identity_path, state_path, history_path all point under /var/lib/fwdsvc/ (e.g. /var/lib/fwdsvc/identity) — ~/ doesn't expand under a system user.
  4. Drop this in /etc/systemd/system/fwdsvc.service:
    [Unit]
    Description=Reticulum forwarding service (group chat)
    After=network-online.target
    Wants=network-online.target
    
    [Service]
    Type=simple
    User=fwdsvc
    Group=fwdsvc
    ExecStart=/usr/local/bin/fwdsvc -config /etc/fwdsvc/config.toml
    Restart=on-failure
    RestartSec=5
    # Optional hardening:
    NoNewPrivileges=true
    ProtectSystem=strict
    ProtectHome=true
    ReadWritePaths=/var/lib/fwdsvc
    PrivateTmp=true
    
    [Install]
    WantedBy=multi-user.target
    
  5. Enable and start:
    sudo systemctl daemon-reload
    sudo systemctl enable --now fwdsvc
    sudo journalctl -u fwdsvc -f
    

Raspberry Pi

Same as Linux + systemd. Pick the right binary for your Pi:

  • Pi 4/5 with 64-bit OS → fwdsvc-linux-arm64
  • Pi 2/3 with 32-bit OS → fwdsvc-linux-armv7
  • Pi Zero / Pi 1 → fwdsvc-linux-armv6

If you have a real LoRa modem (RNode, etc.), run upstream rnsd alongside fwdsvc with the radio attached, and point fwdsvc at rnsd via tcp_client → 127.0.0.1:4242. fwdsvc doesn't speak serial / LoRa directly — rnsd is the radio half.

Windows

fwdsvc-windows-amd64.exe runs the same way:

.\fwdsvc-windows-amd64.exe -config "$env:USERPROFILE\.fwdsvc\config.toml"

For unattended startup, register it with Task Scheduler to run on boot as a specific user (Action = "Start a program", Program = fwdsvc-windows-amd64.exe, Arguments = -config ...\config.toml, Trigger = "At startup", Settings = "Restart on failure"). Or use NSSM to install it as a Windows service if you prefer that workflow.

macOS

Either a launchd plist in ~/Library/LaunchAgents/ or just running under a tmux/screen session. The binary is the same Mach-O universal-ish format; allow it through Gatekeeper the first time: xattr -d com.apple.quarantine fwdsvc-darwin-arm64.

Identity backup

If you redeploy to a different machine and only carry config.toml over, you'd lose the service's identity — and therefore its destination hash — without it. To make config.toml self-sufficient:

  1. Run fwdsvc once. It writes ~/.fwdsvc/identity.b64.txt (mode 0600) on first-run identity generation. Same secrecy class as the identity file itself.
  2. Open that file and copy the base64 string.
  3. In config.toml under [service]:
    identity_b64 = "<paste here>"
    
  4. Restart. The log will read:
    identity loaded from config (identity_b64); ignoring …/identity
    

After that, config.toml alone is enough to restore the service on any machine — same identity, same destination hash, same chat for every existing member.

Running multiple groups in parallel

Each group chat is one fwdsvc instance — one identity, one destination hash, one config, one running process. To host several groups on the same machine, run one instance per group. The only hard rule:

Every instance needs its own identity_path, state_path, and history_path. Two processes sharing an identity both answer to the same destination hash and both fan out every message, so members receive duplicates. This is also why a restart script is a bad idea — if it starts a new process without reliably killing the old one, the leftovers keep forwarding and you get echoes. Let a supervisor (systemd) own the single process instead.

Full worked example: configs/multi-group/ has four ready-to-run configs — two public and two private (locked) groups — plus a README with the systemd and by-hand launch commands. The rest of this section walks through the same pattern inline.

Give each group a config with distinct paths — e.g. /etc/fwdsvc/groupA.toml:

[service]
display_name  = "Group A"
identity_path = "/var/lib/fwdsvc/groupA/identity"
state_path    = "/var/lib/fwdsvc/groupA/state.json"
history_path  = "/var/lib/fwdsvc/groupA/history.json"

and /etc/fwdsvc/groupB.toml the same but under groupB/ with display_name = "Group B". They can share one upstream interface (the same tcp_client peer or a local rnsd) or use different ones — that's independent of keeping their state separate.

With systemd, a templated unit runs one supervised process per group. Drop this in /etc/systemd/system/fwdsvc@.service:

[Unit]
Description=Reticulum group chat (%i)
After=network-online.target
Wants=network-online.target

[Service]
Type=simple
User=fwdsvc
Group=fwdsvc
ExecStart=/usr/local/bin/fwdsvc -config /etc/fwdsvc/%i.toml
Restart=on-failure
RestartSec=5
NoNewPrivileges=true
ProtectSystem=strict
ProtectHome=true
ReadWritePaths=/var/lib/fwdsvc
PrivateTmp=true

[Install]
WantedBy=multi-user.target

%i expands to the name after the @, so fwdsvc@groupA reads /etc/fwdsvc/groupA.toml. Enable each group and tail its own journal:

sudo systemctl enable --now fwdsvc@groupA fwdsvc@groupB
sudo journalctl -u fwdsvc@groupA -f

To confirm you're running exactly one process per group (and no orphans from an earlier manual start), pgrep -af fwdsvc should list one line per group and nothing more. Each instance is independent for resource purposes — see Scaling and resource use.


Operations

State on disk

Everything lives in the directory whose paths you configured in [service] (default ~/.fwdsvc/):

File Purpose Backup-worthy?
config.toml Your config. Optionally embeds the identity. Yes
identity Service identity (64 bytes). Lose it → lose your destination hash. Yes (or use identity_b64)
identity.b64.txt Base64 form of identity, written on first-run for backup. Yes
state.json Roster + banlist. Atomic writes. Yes
history.json Replay ring buffer. Optional (loss only affects replay-on-join)
outbound.json Pending outbound retries. Optional (loss costs at most a few queued messages)
announces.json Cached peer paths. No (regenerates from inbound announces)
fwdsvc.log If log_path is set, the rolling daemon log. No

Logs

Without log_path, everything goes to stdout — let systemd journal or your terminal absorb it. With log_path, both stdout and the file get the same lines. Each log line is RFC3339-ish timestamped to the microsecond. Examples worth recognising:

Pattern Meaning
interface tcp_client connected: … TCP interface up.
announce verified (new|returning): … We learned a path to a peer.
cmd from=<hash> name=/<cmd> A command arrived.
cmd reply queued: … The reply went onto the outbound queue.
outbound: attempt N/5 to <hash> failed: … A delivery attempt failed; retrying.
outbound: failing message id=… after 5 attempts: … Gave up after the retry budget.
resource sender: ADV retry N/4 for <hash> Resource transfer's ADV phase is retrying because the receiver hasn't requested any parts yet.
nick from announce: adopted "X" for … Auto-defaulted a nickname from an inbound announce (v1.3.5+).
tcp interface … disconnected: … — reconnecting Upstream TCP drop; supervisor will redial with backoff (v1.3.6+).
tcp interface … reconnected Reconnect succeeded; interface is live again (v1.3.6+).

Scaling and resource use

A few load-related facts worth knowing before you grow the roster past a few dozen — none are currently a problem at typical sizes but they shape what you'd notice first if you pushed harder:

  • Outbound queue depth scales linearly with active roster. Each inbound chat message produces one outbound.json entry per active (non-paused) recipient. A 60-member roster + one message in flight = up to ~59 pending entries. They drain promptly when recipients are reachable; an unreachable recipient rides retries with exponential backoff (10 s → 60 s cap, each attempt also waiting up to 15 s for a delivery proof). With the propagation fallback active that's direct_attempts tries (default 3, ~75 s) before the message is handed to the node; without a node it's the full 5 attempts (~3 minutes) before the queue gives up.
  • Drain concurrency is fixed at 8 workers, not scaled with roster size (outboundWorkers constant in internal/service/outbound.go). Eight absorbs several concurrent 15-second delivery-proof waits on offline members without head-of-line blocking replies to online ones. For very large rosters (hundreds of members) on a fast interface, raising the constant and rebuilding would speed up fan-out.
  • No upper bound on pending depth. Nothing rejects new messages when the queue is long. In steady state the queue is bounded by chat cadence × the per-recipient retry window, not by anything explicit. Worth knowing if you ever script a flood through the relay.
  • outbound.json is rewritten on every Enqueue — fanning out one message to N recipients does N full-file writes, each marshaling up to N entries (O(N²) in disk write volume per fan-out). Negligible at current sizes; the first thing that would need a batched-persist refactor if the roster grew toward several hundred.
  • Attachments are not persisted. Per-message LXMF fields (e.g. a forwarded FIELD_IMAGE) live in memory only — a crash between enqueue and send drops the image but keeps the text body, which re-sends on restart. Acceptable degradation; sender can always resend.
  • History buffer is bounded by replay.count (default 100). Older forwarded lines roll off when a new one is appended.

Troubleshooting

My users never see replies to /users (or other commands). A slow or stale path causes Link / Resource sends to time out. Try /announce from an admin to push a fresh announce of the daemon into the mesh, and have the affected user re-announce from their client. Use /path <user> (admin) to see what the daemon knows about reaching them — if LinkActive=false and the announce is many hours old, the path is the problem, not fwdsvc. Restarting the affected user's client usually re-announces it immediately.

My users never see ANY messages from me. Verify the daemon is actually reaching the network: look for interface tcp_client connected at startup, and announce verified lines (which mean inbound traffic is flowing). If neither shows up after 30s, the configured [[interfaces]] address isn't reachable from this host.

/join worked but nothing forwards. Check the sender isn't paused (/users would show [paused]). Check the daemon log — if a forward fails 5/5 times for a recipient, you'll see one failing message id=… line and that recipient missed that message, but the chat continues for everyone else.

The destination hash changed after a redeploy. You lost the identity. Either restore the identity file or, better, set identity_b64 in config.toml so this can never happen again.

Path table looks stale. rm ~/.fwdsvc/announces.json and restart — the cache will rebuild from live announces (cost: one announce_interval of waiting for path discovery).

Upgrading

  1. Stop the service.
  2. Replace the binary.
  3. Start the service.

The on-disk state format is stable; new versions read older state.json, history.json, outbound.json, announces.json files. If a future release ever breaks compatibility it'll be called out in the release notes.

Removing an admin or mod

There is no /promote or /demote runtime command — admin/mod membership is config-only by design (auditable via git diff). Edit admins or mods in config.toml, restart.


Wire-format support

Below are the parts of the Reticulum / LXMF stack fwdsvc actually speaks. Each one has at least one of: a static byte-level test vector against canonical Python output, a passing live subprocess interop test against rns 1.2.0 + LXMF 0.9.6, or confirmed live round-trip with a third-party LXMF client.

  • Identity — X25519 + Ed25519 keypair, on-disk format, identity and destination hash derivation (SPEC §1).
  • Token cipher — AES-256-CBC + HMAC-SHA256 + HKDF-SHA256 with the identity_hash salt gotcha (SPEC §3).
  • Packet header — HEADER_1 / HEADER_2 codec including the hashable-part rule that makes proofs survive HEADER_1↔HEADER_2 in flight (SPEC §2).
  • HDLC framing — for tcp_client interfaces (SPEC §8.2).
  • Announce — build, parse, verify (with and without ratchet), including the SPEC §9.3 msgpack bin-vs-str gotcha for app_data.
  • Opportunistic LXMF — full sign / encrypt / decrypt / verify in both directions, including SPEC §5.6 dual-msgpack-variant tolerance.
  • PROOF emission and tracking (SPEC §6.5) — every inbound CTX_NONE DATA at a SINGLE destination is acknowledged with a 64-byte implicit-form proof so senders' PacketReceipts resolve. Outbound opportunistic sends track the recipient's proof in return (accepting implicit and explicit forms): Send blocks up to 15 s for it, so an offline recipient surfaces as a failed attempt that the retry queue — and the propagation fallback — can act on, instead of a silent fire-and-forget "success".
  • Path requests (SPEC §7.1) — when a sender we can't verify contacts us, we issue a path? broadcast; a path-aware relay's path-response announce gives us their public key. Per-target 60 s dedup window with periodic sweep.
  • HEADER_2 originator conversion (SPEC §2.3) — outbound DATA to a multi-hop recipient is HEADER_2 with the cached next-hop transport_id.
  • Reticulum Link (SPEC §6) — full LINKREQUEST / LRPROOF handshake (byte-exact against the spec test vector), ECDH+HKDF session keys, link-form Token cipher, link-DATA framing, SPEC §6.5.6 explicit-form 96-byte link PROOFs. Idle links auto-close after 15 min; KEEPALIVE every 4 min.
  • Delivery stamps (SPEC §5.7.2, outbound) — when a recipient's announce declares a stamp_cost (§4.3 element [1]), grinds the proof-of-work over the message_id on the 3000-round (768 KiB) workblock and carries it as payload element [4], so peers that enforce stamps accept our direct sends. Capped at 16 bits: the cost is chosen by the recipient and the grind runs once per member per message, so an absurd demand is refused outright rather than allowed to occupy an outbound worker. Inbound validation is out of scope — a stamp we receive is carried through unverified.
  • Propagation-node submission (SPEC §5.8, sender side) — packs the propagated wire form (dest_hash || Token-encrypted body, wrapped in the msgpack upload envelope), parses lxmf.propagation announce app_data (the strict 7-element §5.8.5 shape, including the [5]-as-list interop gotcha), grinds §5.7.2 propagation stamps (1000-round PN workblock) when the node requires them, and uploads over a Link — single link DATA or Resource by size. The server role and /get retrieval are out of scope (members' clients fetch their own mail).
  • Resource transfer (SPEC §10) — full sender and receiver. Send: link-encrypt the body, slice into raw-ciphertext parts, advertise via msgpack ADV, fulfill receiver-driven REQs, validate the receiver's RESOURCE_PRF in constant time. Receive: parse ADV, fetch parts, verify, decrypt. Roughly 1 MiB / 74 parts per resource; inbound c=1 (bz2-compressed) and n>74 ADVs are rejected (bomb defense — see docs/resource-security-audit.md). Multi-segment transfers (§10.11) are refused in both directions (SetMaxResourceSegments(1)): the send path is single-segment, so accepting one inbound would mean reassembling a body fwdsvc then could not relay. An oversize sender gets a RESOURCE_RCL and stops retransmitting rather than timing out. max_attachment_bytes drops the oversize field before forwarding, which is what keeps every relayed message inside one segment to begin with.

Delivery-path selection is automatic: ≤ ~280 bytes is opportunistic, ≤ 431 bytes plaintext over a Reticulum Link is single-packet Link DATA, anything bigger is Resource transfer over that same Link. So long /users replies on a big roster ship the full list — size is not a delivery constraint.


Reactions: what a client must implement

Reactions ride on FIELD_REACTION (0x40, LXMF 1.0.0). Because fwdsvc re-originates every message (re-signs it as the service), a client needs the four things below for reactions to work through the relay. Full wire detail, rationale, and the cross-client convention are in docs/reaction-attribution.md — written so Sideband / MeshChatX / Columba / ratspeak (or any LXMF client) can implement against it.

  1. Decode nested integer-keyed field maps. A reaction's fields are {0x40: {0x00: <raw 32-byte target message_id>, 0x01: <UTF-8 content>}} — the inner dict has integer keys. Many msgpack libraries decode a nested map value into a string-keyed map and reject integer keys; Go's vmihailenco/msgpack fails with invalid code=0 decoding string/bytes length and drops the entire message. Decode into an untyped / any-keyed map at every nesting level (Go: Decoder.SetMapDecoder(func(d){ return d.DecodeUntypedMap() })), and tolerate any integer key width (int8/int64/…) and bytes-or-str values. The same applies to FIELD_COMMENT (0x41) and FIELD_CONTINUATION (0x42). This is the #1 cause of "reactions silently don't work" — the tell is that replies (0x30, raw bytes at the top level) work but reactions vanish, and over a Link the sender retries forever (it never gets a delivery proof).

  2. Emit reactions on 0x40 with empty content/title: 0x00 = the raw 32-byte message_id of the target as your client received it, 0x01 = the reaction text (e.g. an emoji). Do not use the pre-1.0.0 fields[16] shape — fwdsvc no longer accepts it.

  3. Send the reaction to the relay. No special routing needed: the relayed message's source_hash is the relay (we re-sign), so a reaction addressed to the message you're reacting to naturally goes back to the relay for fan-out.

  4. Attribute by the originator stamp. So reactions aren't all attributed to the relay, fwdsvc stamps the reactor's source_hash into custom fields. When a received reaction carries fields[0xFB] == "originator-identity" (exact UTF-8) and a well-formed fields[0xFC] (the reactor's raw 16-byte source_hash — its lxmf.delivery destination hash, the same value a direct reaction carries and what contacts are keyed by, per SPEC §5.9.8 / §9.1; not the identity hash, which would orphan the lookup), attribute / aggregate by that hash instead of the carrying source_hash; fall back to source_hash when the stamp is absent. ⚠️ The stamp is unauthenticated — honor it only when the reaction arrived via a trusted relay (e.g. the source that delivered the reacted-to message), and validate 0xFC is 16 bytes, else a direct peer can forge attribution to anyone. Aggregate by (reactor-identity, reaction-content). Full convention + the trust rules: docs/reaction-attribution.md.

Target binding "just works": the relay rewrites the reaction's target message_id per recipient (each member computed a different id for the same bubble), so you react with the id your client holds and it lands on the right message everywhere.


Limitations

The implementation is intentionally minimal — just enough Reticulum + LXMF to run a group-chat hub. Notable gaps:

  • Single TCP interface typetcp_client only. No LoRa / RNode-serial, no UDP, no AutoInterface (LAN multicast), no I2P. A Pi with a real LoRa modem will need to run upstream rnsd alongside fwdsvc and point fwdsvc at rnsd over TCP.
  • No transit relay. fwdsvc is a leaf node — it doesn't forward third-party packets.
  • No automatic TCP reconnect. If the configured tcp_client interface drops, the service logs and continues; you have to restart it. Use systemd Restart=on-failure (already in the recipe above).
  • No ratchets on our own key. fwdsvc publishes no §7.3 ratchet, so every message sent to the group is encrypted to our long-term X25519 key and a future compromise of it decrypts past traffic. Outbound is better off: since the library gained ratchet support we encrypt to a peer's announced ratchet automatically when they publish one, so what we send to a ratcheting member is already forward-secret. Enabling one on our side is a config and key-rotation question, not a protocol gap.
  • Stamps: both directions, charging is opt-in. Both §5.7 proof-of- work flavors are generated — delivery stamps for recipients whose announce declares a stamp_cost, and propagation stamps for nodes that require them. Inbound stamps are now validated and scored as well: set inbound_stamp_cost and every sender pays before the fan-out, with enforce_inbound_stamps deciding whether a message that underpays is dropped or merely logged. Both default to off, so out of the box a sender still costs the group nothing to message and the fan-out is worth rate-limiting by other means. Tickets (§5.7.3) are supported by the library but not wired up here, so a member has no way to earn an exemption from the grind yet.
  • Propagation: sender side only. fwdsvc can submit messages to a propagation node (see [propagation]), but does not act as a propagation node itself and does not retrieve its own inbound mail via /get — people messaging the group need the service reachable directly.
  • Limited LXMF field support. FIELD_IMAGE (6) and the upstream LXMF 1.0.0 message-meta fields — reply-to (0x30=48 + 0x31=49), reactions (FIELD_REACTION 0x40=64), comments (0x41=65), and continuations (0x42=66) — are forwarded through group chat by default; FIELD_FILE_ATTACHMENTS (5) and FIELD_AUDIO (7) can be enabled per-operator via forwarded_fields. Stickers, embedded LXMs, telemetry, icon-appearance, and command fields are still parsed but discarded. A sender whose attachment (file, image or audio) is refused by the policy gets a private reply saying so — otherwise a voice clip reassembles perfectly and then vanishes with no signal to anyone. Refused metadata (a reaction, say) is silent, since the user did not choose to attach it.
  • Reactions / reply-to lifetime. Because the relay re-emits each forwarded message under its own identity, every recipient computes a different message_id for the same bubble — so cross-client reactions and replies need per-recipient rewriting. fwdsvc does this in-memory via a TTL cache (id_cache_ttl, default 24h), so reactions / replies to messages relayed within that window bind correctly on every other member's client. Past the TTL (or after a service restart, since the cache is not persisted) the binding falls back to legacy behavior — reactions don't render, replies show only their fields[0x31] quote preview.
  • Reaction attribution. Because the relay re-signs each reaction as itself, a reaction's source_hash becomes fwdsvc — and a reaction has no body to carry a [Nick] prefix, so naive relaying collapses every reaction onto the service. fwdsvc stamps the original reactor's source_hash (its destination hash, what contacts are keyed by — SPEC §9.1) into the upstream custom fields (FIELD_CUSTOM_TYPE 0xFB = "originator-identity", FIELD_CUSTOM_DATA 0xFC = reactor source_hash) so cooperating clients attribute the reaction to the reactor, not the relay. The 0x40 wire format is untouched and the stamp is purely additive (spec-only clients ignore it). This is an app-layer interop convention documented for other clients in docs/reaction-attribution.md. Replies need no stamp — they carry a body and ride the [Nick] path.
  • No voice / audio. Text-only. We register only the lxmf.delivery aspect — never call.audio. Some MeshChat users see a brief "incoming call" notification attributed to fwdsvc shortly after our announce. Audit on our side ruled out every code path that could possibly target a call.audio dest_hash; suspected upstream cause + diagnostic ask in docs/meshchat-call-codec-mismatch-issue.md. Not a fwdsvc bug.
  • IFAC packets rejected. Packets with the IFAC flag set are refused at parse with errIFACUnsupported. Real IFAC support would require new interface config and is not on the roadmap.

Build from source

Requires Go 1.26 or newer.

git clone https://github.com/thatSFguy/reticulum-group-chat
cd reticulum-group-chat
go mod tidy
go build -o fwdsvc ./cmd/fwdsvc
go test ./...

Cross-compile every release target into build/:

./scripts/build-all.sh
ls -lh build/

Verification

Three increasingly strong levels of test:

# 1. Default unit + spec test vectors. Static byte-level equality
#    against canonical Python rns 1.2.0 / LXMF 0.9.6 vectors loaded
#    from ../reticulum-specifications/test-vectors/ (skipped cleanly
#    if the spec sibling repo isn't checked out).
go test ./...

# 2. Live Python subprocess interop. Spawns a Python helper that
#    drives upstream rns + LXMF directly and exchanges fresh
#    announce + opportunistic-LXMF bytes with the Go code in BOTH
#    directions. Requires `pip install rns lxmf` and `python` on
#    PATH. Skipped otherwise. Also runs on CI on every push.
go test -tags=interop ./tests/interop/...

Plus a live mesh interop check during development: the service runs against a community-run testnet entry node (rns.chicagonomad.net, rns.michmesh.net) and is exercised end-to-end with Sideband / NomadNet / MeshChat — announce propagation, opportunistic LXMF send, PROOF emission, path-request resolving an unannounced sender, Link + Resource delivery, round-tripping back to the mobile UI.


Project info

License

MIT.

Contributing

This implementation tracks the canonical Reticulum / LXMF spec directly. Wire-format changes should reference the relevant SPEC.md section number in the commit message and either include a static test vector or pass live interop.

Issues that find a discrepancy between this implementation and upstream Python rns / LXMF: please cite the upstream file:line and a runtime reproduction in the report.